Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise) - The Beatles
Select a song or an artist- and read about and hear these great recordings:
Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise) (1967)
Although for most listeners “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise)” was the identical track to the title trac of the Sgt. Peppers album, in fact, the reprise is faster and with different lyrics.
In the context of the pop-rock album format the idea of a reprise is unprecedented. In it, the band returns - but with a stunning difference: it is no longer the “raucous fun man, promising smiles and good times” that the opening track did.
The concept of a reprise is a sufficiently familiar one from the world of opera and musical stage show. But this was a Beatles’ album and it should have been viewed as out of place- yet it fits in perfectly with the overall feel, concept and sound of the album.
Beatle scholar Wilfred Mellers opines:
“In its return, Sgt. Pepper has lost its show-biz glamour, or recognizes it as illusory.”
Opening with McCartney’s 1-2-3-4 count-in and Lennon’s cheeky “bye”, “The Reprise” was one of the few songs in the entire Beatle canon that featured all four band members on vocals.
The backing of the outer two main sections of the track is comprised of acoustic and electric guitar, piano, bass, and drums, all four of which stand out in terms of tasteful restraint - but particularly the drums.
Musicologist Tim Riley defines Ringo’s simple drum solo as “nothing but the primal beat in all its glory, so charged and spirited that any showy twist would lessen it.”
“Hoisting the harmonies up on key for a dramatic last verse is normally a Tin Pan Alley cliché, but putting it to use in this song shows the Beatles’ respect for the genre. The kick it gives propels wordplay: Sgt. Pepper’s one and only Lonely Hearts Club Band/It’s getting very near the end, as if they were worried about falling off the end of the record.”
“The Reprise” features progressive tonality - the compositional practice whereby a piece of music does not finish in the key in which it began, but instead “progresses” to an ending in a different key. The Beatles exhibited this trait in many of the songs of this time period.
According to Beatle expert Alan Pollack, the group had always gone in for what he calls, staggered or layered arrangements:
“The outer groove can be seen, beyond mere prank, as further twist on the gesture of the final chord. By coming so suddenly out of total silence after you’ve assumed the show is over, it only serves to heighten in retrospect the sense of eternal desolation created by the final chord’s dying away.”
In his book on Sgt. Peppers, Allan Moore wrote that the insistence on Sgt. Pepper’s loneliness begins to suggest an exit from the false persona of the album:
“Sgt. Pepper may be lonely, but the verve of the performance makes it clear that his band is not.”
The track’s central meaning could be that the band is lonely, and it is performing- both of which are interrelated: performers can generally be seen as lonely people; lonely people perform when they pretend not to be lonely and in an attempt to escape their loneliness.
|Make a suggestion to improve this song profile|